Rent safe and private dog parks hosted by locals

The Best Dog Trainers in San Antonio, TX of 2024

David Adams photo

David Adams

July 10, 2024

Dog Trainers

This is a list of the top dog trainers in San Antonio, TX, based on votes from the Sniffspot community and the general public.

  • Hannah Barrera Photo

    Hannah Barrera

    CPDT-KA, CGC Evaluator

    Aggressive dog training, Reactive dog training, Service dog training, Puppy dog training, In home dog training

    San Antonio

    .


  • Mitchell Adcock Photo

    Mitchell Adcock

    Aggressive dog training, Agility training, Off leash training, Herding training, Deaf dog training, Protection/guard dog training

    Born and raised in central FL, I joined the Marine Corps at age 17. After a couple of years spent working as a military police officer in California and Japan, I was blessed with the opportunity to go to school and become a Military Working Dog handler. After working with my (now retired) working dog Xxcalibur for close to three years, I was afforded the opportunity to become a Military Working...


  • Mel Alcoser Photo

    Mel Alcoser

    Agility training, Puppy training, Protection/guard dog training

    Mel was born and raised in Southern California. After graduating high school in 2017, Mel enlisted in the US Army as a Military Working Dog Handler. She completed military working dog school and was stationed at Fort Hood in Killeen, TX. In 2020, she deployed with her dual-purpose Military Working Dog Cinka to Iraq, where they were attached to an Infantry Battalion belonging to the 82nd Airborn...


  • Taylor Annino Photo

    Taylor Annino

    From a young age, Taylor has loved animals of all shapes and sizes. Her first introduction to the dog world was her grandmother putting the Westminster Dog Show on the TV for them to watch together. She’s worked with neonatal litters and helped find placement for numerous rescues. She’s worked in veterinary medicine and loves to care for and help animals. However, she wanted to be more hand...


  • Riley Blaylock Photo

    Riley Blaylock

    Meet Owner and Trainer, Riley Blaylock! Riley’s journey into the world of dog training began in the Marine Corps, where he served for 5 years as a Military Police Officer stationed at Marine Corps Base Quantico. During that time he was qualified as a Military Working Dog Handler by the 341st Training Squadron at Lackland Air Force Base in San Antonio, TX, where he graduated at the top of his ...


  • Rustin Blaylock Photo

    Rustin Blaylock

    Meet Owner and Trainer, Rustin Blaylock! He is a passionate dog trainer with a unique background. Having served in the Marine Corps for 4 years as a Military Police Officer stationed at Marine Corps Base Lejeune, Rustin brings discipline and dedication to his training approach. His expertise extends to canine companions, having been Qualified as a Military Working Dog Handler by the Air Force‚Ä...


  • Jeff Chappell Photo

    Jeff Chappell

    Agility training, Puppy training, Protection/guard dog training

    Jeff was born and raised in Atlanta, GA but moved frequently during his childhood due to his father being in the Army. Growing up, Jeff was led by his adventurous spirit and love for animals. After graduating from high school in 2017, Jeff decided to follow in his father’s footsteps and pursue a career of serving his country and joined the US Army, shipping off to basic training two weeks aft...


  • Susan Cole Photo

    Susan Cole

    Puppy training, In home training

    I have owned dogs all my life and my life turned upside down when I adopted a young cattle dog mix named Pepper. We had been told that Pepper was "good with other dogs", which turned out to be the farthest from the truth. She fought with our other dogs and we could not walk her in our neighborhood without her turning into "Cujo" at the sight of other dogs. We were told by many local trainers...


  • Jan Echavarry Photo

    Jan Echavarry

    Aggressive dog training, Agility training, Puppy training, Herding training, In home training

    My love of training began 17 years ago when I began assisting at a local dog-rescue facility in South Texas. I learned that most of the dogs needed basic skills, just as much as they needed a permanent, loving home. Their inability to interact was a major reason that they were unwanted, through no fault of their own. On my weekly visits to local pet stores, I became interested and completed a t...


  • Zach Fresquez Photo

    Zach Fresquez

    Agility training, Puppy training, Protection/guard dog training

    Zach was born and raised right here in San Antonio, TX. He grew up always having a family dog and loved to interact with all animals, but never thought a future career as an animal trainer was in his future.

    He graduated from Texas State University with a degree in Applied Mathematics in 2017. Since graduation, Zach’s career has centered around educating and advising people in a prof...


  • Alexis Gutierrez Photo

    Alexis Gutierrez

    Agility training, Puppy training, In home training

    Hi, future family! My name is Alexis, but I go by, “Lexie”

    I was born and raised in San Antonio, TX! I am happily married with, 3 daughters and 4 dogs of my own! Ever since I was a little girl, I have always had a passion for working with dogs. Although when I was younger I would just smother them and expect them to love me üòù

    I started out at a local pet store as a tra...


  • Angel Gutierrez Photo

    Angel Gutierrez

    Agility training, Puppy training, In home training

    My name is Angel. I am your next dog trainer for your beloved pup! I have called San Antonio my home for most of my life. I am married to a beautiful wife and have 3 beautiful daughters along with four furry dogs that are a part of our family.

    I have had various careers in my path but by far I found my calling was working with dogs. I always had a fondness for dogs and how much they c...


  • Bryan Gutierrez Photo

    Bryan Gutierrez

    Agility training, Puppy training, Protection/guard dog training

    Bryan grew up in the Great Plains of Western Nebraska and has always had a passion for outdoors and animals. His passion led him to join the Boy Scouts of America at a young age which he continued through numerous challenges and adventures until he accomplished the highest rank, Eagle Scout.

    Upon graduating high school, Bryan joined the Air Force in 2012 and started his first military...


  • James Haney Photo

    James Haney

    James Haney grew up with a strong love of dogs. As an adult, he joined the armed forces where he served as a Military Working Dog Handler and also as a Kennel Master. Throughout his 13 year career in the working dog field, James noticed that going outside of just what the military offered and exploring different aspects of the sport and service dog world really helped him to handle just about a...


  • Morgan Hanson Photo

    Morgan Hanson

    In home training, Board and train

    Morgan Hanson has been involved in dog training and dog sports for nearly two decades. She recently relocated from Columbus, OH to the San Antonio area. Morgan grew up participating in the sport of agility after leaving the equestrian world. Morgan has had a great deal of success at the national level of competition in the United States, being a 16-time national finalist in multiple different a...


  • Glenda Herrin Photo

    Glenda Herrin

    As a “military brat” born in Oslo, Norway, I spent my childhood moving around the globe until my father retired from the Air Force. I chose to follow in his footsteps, and served 20 years in the Air Force as a German and Russian Linguist/Translator.

    In 2000, I retired in Germany, earned a Bachelor of Arts Degree in German from the University of Maryland, and worked in various teach...


  • Angie Leonberger Photo

    Angie Leonberger

    Growing up in a family of animal lovers & conservationists, Angie came by her devotion to animals of all species honestly. As soon as she was able, she became employed at an AAHA accredited veterinary hospital where she began her journey towards what would become her career. She attended Illinois State University through the Animal Science sequence where she furthered her knowledge in animal hu...


  • Alex Marquissee Photo

    Alex Marquissee

    Agility training, Puppy training, Protection/guard dog training

    Alex grew up in Appleton, Wisconsin surrounded by dogs as family pets and always wanted a career where he could work with dogs. Alex was able to make that dream become a reality when he was selected to become a Military Working Dog Handler during his service in the Marine Corps.

    Alex served in the United States Marine Corps from 2014 until 2022. During his distinguished service as a Ma...


  • Lulu Melvin Photo

    Lulu Melvin

    Agility training, Puppy training, Protection/guard dog training

    Lulu, a vibrant native to San Antonio, graduated from the University of Texas San Antonio with a bachelor’s degree in Anthropology. She stumbled into the world of bartending where she honed her interpersonal and customer service skills for 7 years. She loves an active environment and genuinely enjoys connecting with people and their stories! Also, having two dogs, a cat, and reptiles at home,...


  • Andrew Quillin Photo

    Andrew Quillin

    Meet owner and trainer Andrew “Gunny” Quillin. Active duty Marine turned canine trainer! As an active-duty Marine with 18 years of service as a KC-130 engine mechanic, Andrew brings a unique blend of discipline and dedication to the world of canine companionship. Currently stationed at Marine Corps Base Hawaii, Andrew’s passion extends beyond military duties. For the past 3 years, he has...


  • Savannah Reynolds Photo

    Savannah Reynolds

    Savannah attended her first dog show when she was 8 years old and was instantly hooked. She has been working professionally in the animal industry for over 13 years. As well as training, she is an all-breed master groomer. Savannah has employment experience in multiple faucets of the animal industry including veterinary medicine, animal grooming, and neonatal/wildlife rehabilitation.

    S...


  • Dakoda Riddle Photo

    Dakoda Riddle

    Aggressive dog training, Agility training, Herding training, Protection/guard dog training, In home training

    Dakoda Riddle served in the United States Air Force from 2009-2020 as a military police K9 handler where Dakoda held the positions of handler, trainer and eventually kennel master. During that time, he led and orchestrated countless multi-agency exercises and training scenarios to ensure his teams were proficient in everything from explosive detection and IED recognition to tactical entries and...


  • Marlene Ring Photo

    Marlene Ring

    Agility training, In home training

    My mission is to help you be successful in building a better communication and relationship with your dog. Perfecting this positive dog training method has been my personal passion since 2000.

    My training does not rely on punishment or force. Behaviors are taught using positive reinforcements, rewarding the dog for the behaviors that we want and redirecting the behaviors that we do not...


  • Alex Schnell Photo

    Alex Schnell

    Aggressive dog training, Agility training, Puppy training, Herding training, Protection/guard dog training

    Alex grew up in western South Dakota. During his childhood, he was an avid dog lover. Alex first saw the amazing potential that dogs had watching bird dogs work the fields while hunting. Alex continued to work with hunting breeds until he enlisted in the Marine Corps in 2012.

    With a desire to continue working with dogs in the military, Alex was selected to become a Military Working Dog...


  • Maddie Schnell Photo

    Maddie Schnell

    Agility training, Puppy training, Protection/guard dog training

    Maddie Schnell was born and raised in Rapid City, SD. She grew up playing a multitude of sports, loving the outdoors, and her family always had a house full of dogs. Maddie played four years of collegiate softball at Augustana University while majoring in Elementary Education with a minor in English. She taught Elementary and Middle School for over 6 years between her time in South Dakota, Nort...


  • Cyndi Smasal Photo

    Cyndi Smasal

    Puppy training, In home training

    Cyndi Smasal is an exceptionally knowledgeable canine expert. Certified as a Professional Dog Trainer (CPDT-KA) from the esteemed Certification Council for Professional Dog Trainers® (CCPDT®), Cyndi is committed to helping dogs and pet parents build strong bonds. With a comprehensive certification exam passed, over 1000 hours of experience working with clients, and a reference from a veterina...


Welcome to San Antonio’s list of top dog trainers. The San Antonio, Texas list is based on 105 votes from the Texas Sniffspot community. Only the San Antonio dog trainers with the top number of votes made this list. Trainers are ordered by number of votes, with Hannah Barrera at the top of this list with 105 votes. We also counted 1508 votes for Texas, with the remaining trainers listed outside of San Antonio.

Our rankings include trainers certified by CPDT-KA and CGC Evaluator. They also specialize in Puppy training, In home training amongst other training programs.

San Antonio dog trainer services include:

  • Puppy training
  • In home training
  • Agility training
  • Aggressive dog training
  • Protection/guard dog training
  • Herding training
  • Puppy dog training
  • Reactive dog training
  • In home dog training
  • Deaf dog training
  • Board and train
  • Service dog training
  • Off leash training

Behind every successful San Antonio training session lies a passionate professional. Hannah Barrera shares why they chose this path: To help those who don't have a voice.. All 26 trainers on this San Antonio list are committed to positive reinforcement. Trusted San Antonio trainer, Mitchell Adcock, uses the following methods: .

Explore the top dog trainers in San Antonio as voted by our community:

Sniffspot Dog running on field

Get safe exercise for your dog by renting a private dog park near you

See The Best Dog Trainers In Other Cities Near San Antonio

Ordered alphabetically, only included cities where there is enough data to compile a list


See The Best Dog Trainers By Type In San Antonio


FAQ: Meet the Top San Antonio, Texas Dog Trainers

Who are the top-rated dog trainers in San Antonio, Texas?

In San Antonio, Hannah Barrera has earned the highest recognition for their expertise in Aggressive dog training.

What drives San Antonio dog trainers to excel in their services?

Hannah Barrera and other leading trainers in San Antonio are motivated by a passion for helping dogs and their owners. Hannah Barrera was inspired to offer their services in San Antonio because To help those who don't have a voice..

What are the top services offered by San Antonio trainers?

The top trainers in San Antonio, such as Hannah Barrera, specialize in providing Aggressive dog training, Reactive dog training, Service dog training, Puppy dog training, In home dog training. They describe their services as: Private training, basic obedience, reactivity.

What is Hannah Barrera’s best piece of advice for San Antonio dog owners?

Hannah Barrera recommends: Patience. Your dog's behavior makes sense to them.. This advice is particularly relevant for dog owners in San Antonio looking to improve their dog’s behavior.

How can I choose the right trainer in San Antonio for my dog’s needs?

Choosing the right trainer in San Antonio involves considering their services, such as , as well as their qualifications, including CPDT-KA, CGC Evaluator.

Why are certifications important for San Antonio dog trainers?

Certifications like CPDT-KA, CGC Evaluator are crucial for trainers in San Antonio as they ensure that each trainer has the necessary skills and knowledge to provide effective and positive training.

Get your dog the safe enrichment they need by renting a Sniffspot

Sniffspot Dog swimming in pool
David Adams photo

David Adams

July 10, 2024

Dog Trainers

About Sniffspot

Sniffspot is a community marketplace that enables anyone to rent land by-the-hour as a safe and private dog park.

Follow us

Find Sniffspot on your favorite social media

TiktokInstagramFacebookYoutube
Related articles
The Best San Diego, California Dog Parks thumbnailThe Best San Diego, California Dog Parks
Bikejoring: What is It & How to Get Started thumbnailBikejoring: What is It & How to Get Started
Explore the Miniature Poodle: Genuine Tips from 9,000+ Owners thumbnailExplore the Miniature Poodle: Genuine Tips from 9,000+ Owners
All categories

Most recent articles

The Best San Diego, California Dog Parks thumbnailThe Best San Diego, California Dog Parks
The Best San Diego, California Dog Parks thumbnail

The Best San Diego, California Dog Parks

Bikejoring: What is It & How to Get Started thumbnailBikejoring: What is It & How to Get Started
Bikejoring: What is It & How to Get Started thumbnail

Bikejoring: What is It & How to Get Started

Explore the Miniature Poodle: Genuine Tips from 9,000+ Owners thumbnailExplore the Miniature Poodle: Genuine Tips from 9,000+ Owners
Explore the Miniature Poodle: Genuine Tips from 9,000+ Owners thumbnail

Explore the Miniature Poodle: Genuine Tips from 9,000+ Owners

Meet the Jack Russell Terrier: Advice from Real Owners thumbnailMeet the Jack Russell Terrier: Advice from Real Owners
Meet the Jack Russell Terrier: Advice from Real Owners thumbnail

Meet the Jack Russell Terrier: Advice from Real Owners

Explore the Dalmatian: Genuine Tips from Real-World Owners thumbnailExplore the Dalmatian: Genuine Tips from Real-World Owners
Explore the Dalmatian: Genuine Tips from Real-World Owners thumbnail

Explore the Dalmatian: Genuine Tips from Real-World Owners

Meet the Bernese Mountain Dog: Essential Tips from Owners thumbnailMeet the Bernese Mountain Dog: Essential Tips from Owners
Meet the Bernese Mountain Dog: Essential Tips from Owners thumbnail

Meet the Bernese Mountain Dog: Essential Tips from Owners

Top dog guides per area

Dog training guides

  • How to Deal With Food Aggression in Dogs (Facts + Infographic) thumbnail

    How to Deal With Food Aggression in Dogs (Facts + Infographic)

    Does your dog ever growl when you walk by their food dish? Maybe they get possessive of treats, carrying them far away and giving you side-eye when you start to approach — or snarling at your other pets or children if they get too close.

  • Comprehensive Guide to Scent Training for Dogs (Facts + Infographic) thumbnail

    Comprehensive Guide to Scent Training for Dogs (Facts + Infographic)

    As almost every dog owner is aware, the nose of a dog is an amazing thing. Just as they can pick up sounds we can’t hear, their sense of smell and ability to pick up scents is well beyond ours. In fact, dogs have 40 times the number of olfactory receptors as humans.

  • How Much Does it Cost to Train a Service Dog? thumbnail

    How Much Does it Cost to Train a Service Dog?

    More than 80 million Americans rely on their service dogs to help them navigate the world. Task-trained assistance animals perform a huge range of life-changing—in many cases, life-saving—services: These dogs act as eyes for visually impaired handlers, provide mobility support, alert to seizures and blood sugar crashes, interrupt anxiety attacks, remind their people to take medications, and so much more.

  • What is and How to Handle Potty Training Regression thumbnail

    What is and How to Handle Potty Training Regression

    You thought your dog was house trained. Your home was clean from puddles of pee, those dreaded middle-of-the-night bathroom breaks were behind you, and you loved every minute of dog ownership… until your four-legged best friend started using the bathroom inside again. What’s going on?

  • Coprophagia: Why Does Your Dog Eat Poop? thumbnail

    Coprophagia: Why Does Your Dog Eat Poop?

    Ah, poop. We humans think it’s disgusting… but many of our dogs seem to love the stuff. If you’re wondering why your canine companion tries to eat feces (either their own or that of other animals) you’re not alone!

Dog enrichment guides

  • The Best Dog Water Parks in the United States thumbnail

    The Best Dog Water Parks in the United States

    Do you have a water-loving dog looking to burn some energy? There are countless dog parks to visit throughout our country — but some of them become far too hot in the midday sun to be safe for your pets to play. That’s why we’ve put together a list of some of the best dog water parks throughout the United States! At these locations, your pup can frolic, splash, and swim to their heart’s content.

  • Best Toys for Herding Dogs thumbnail

    Best Toys for Herding Dogs

    * All Sniffspot articles are reviewed by certified trainers for quality, please see bottom of article for details *

  • The Best Dog Toys for Aggressive Chewers (Facts + Infographic) thumbnail

    The Best Dog Toys for Aggressive Chewers (Facts + Infographic)

    Does your dog destroy every toy you give them? Is your house littered with remnants of fabric and stuffing of all different sizes? Are you tired of investing in “indestructible” toys only for your pup to still dismantle—or worse, get bored of—them in just a few days?

  • Dog Exercise Calculator: How Much Exercise Does Your Dog Need? thumbnail

    Dog Exercise Calculator: How Much Exercise Does Your Dog Need?

    You’ve been told your dog needs regular exercise. There’s a reason “walking the dog” is a classic daily activity: Frequent excursions give your pup a chance to experience the world, maintain a healthy weight, and — most importantly — spend time with you! Consistent physical activity can also improve their strength, muscle tone, coordination, and mental ability over time.

  • Complete Guide To Herding With Dogs thumbnail

    Complete Guide To Herding With Dogs

    * All Sniffspot articles are reviewed by certified trainers for quality, please see bottom of article for details *

Dog reactivity guides

Sniffspot community guides

  • The State of Public Dog Parks Across the United States thumbnail

    The State of Public Dog Parks Across the United States

    From 2009 to 2020, there was a 40 percent increase in the development of public dog parks. Designated spots for canine exercise have become commonplace in every major city in North America — many pet owners won’t even consider renting an apartment that doesn’t have its own fenced-in pet area for their canine companions.

  • How This Family is Affording Their Dream Property Through Renting it Hourly to Dogs thumbnail

    How This Family is Affording Their Dream Property Through Renting it Hourly to Dogs

    Thousand Oaks, California has been a safe haven for Sniffspot host, Jen, since childhood. Having grown up in busy Santa Barbara, Jen, an introvert from an early age, would seek out solitude and serenity away from tourists attractions and droves of people visiting from elsewhere. “My grandparents own 60 acres about a 30 minute drive from here, and I grew up spending every summer and every holiday visiting them on the ranch,” Jen explained. “In Santa Barbara, we wouldn't go to the beach on the weekend because that's where everybody was, so you'd find places off the beaten path where the tourists weren't. For me, the ranch was just my happy place.” 

  • Host Tips: Ellen K. What Makes Sniffspot Successful for Me thumbnail

    Host Tips: Ellen K. What Makes Sniffspot Successful for Me

    Ellen is the host of Country Pasture Getaway, one of Sniffspot's most popular sniff spots. She has taken the time to write up the lessons she has learned about how to be a great sniff spot host.

  • How this Oregon Farmer is Making a Business From Renting Her Land to Dogs thumbnail

    How this Oregon Farmer is Making a Business From Renting Her Land to Dogs

    Just 20 minutes outside of the busy city of Portland, Oregon, and settled right on the banks of the Columbia River, you’ll find what countless visitors have flocked to the area in search of – mountain views, crisp, clean air, and running water for miles. What you might not expect to find, however, is a hidden oasis designed just for dogs and their people, owned and operated by a farming couple and enjoyed by visitors on two legs, and four.  

  • Host Tips: Fran T. Providing Great Guest Service at our Spot thumbnail

    Host Tips: Fran T. Providing Great Guest Service at our Spot

    Fran is the host of Ranch Setting, one of Sniffspot's most popular spots. She has taken the time to write up the lessons she has learned about how to be a great Sniffspot host.

Top dog trainers in the US

City dog parks guides

  • The Best Indoor Dog Parks in the United States thumbnail

    The Best Indoor Dog Parks in the United States

    Looking for a space to play with your dog no matter what the weather’s like outside? Look no further than our list of the best indoor dog parks in the United States! These climate-controlled spaces are growing in popularity as pet ownership increases throughout the country. As a bonus, many of them also offer dog training, boarding, grooming, or daycare services on the premises.

  • The Best Off-Leash Dog Parks in the United States thumbnail

    The Best Off-Leash Dog Parks in the United States

    Looking for the perfect place to play with your dog? We’ve got you covered! It’s hard to narrow down, but we’ve put together some of the best off-leash dog parks throughout the country so you can plan your next adventure — along with a checklist of what to bring, what to know beforehand, and some frequently asked questions.

  • The Best Las Vegas, Nevada Dog Parks thumbnail

    The Best Las Vegas, Nevada Dog Parks

    Looking for the perfect place to play with your dog in Las Vegas? We’ve got you covered! Take a look at the best local dog parks to plan for your next adventure in Sin City.

  • The Best United States Dog Parks thumbnail

    The Best United States Dog Parks

    Looking for the perfect place to play with your dog? We’ve got you covered!

  • The Best Portland, Oregon Dog Parks thumbnail

    The Best Portland, Oregon Dog Parks

    Looking for the perfect place to play with your dog in Portland? We’ve got you covered! Take a look at the best local dog parks and plan for your next adventure in the City of Roses.

Dogs breeds

  • Explore the German Shepherd Dog: Genuine Tips from Owners thumbnail

    Explore the German Shepherd Dog: Genuine Tips from Owners

    Discover the German Shepherd Dog, a breed celebrated for its intelligence, loyalty, and versatility. Known for its impressive size and smooth, graceful movements, German Shepherds excel in various roles, including as guide, therapy, bomb detection, and police dogs, while being a devoted family companion.

  • Explore the Labrador Retriever: Real Tips from Owners thumbnail

    Explore the Labrador Retriever: Real Tips from Owners

    Discover the Labrador Retriever, a breed celebrated for its playful nature, affectionate temperament, and trainability. Labradors are known for their friendly demeanor and adaptability, making them perfect family companions and versatile working dogs.

  • Explore the Golden Retriever: Genuine Tips from 9,000+ Owners thumbnail

    Explore the Golden Retriever: Genuine Tips from 9,000+ Owners

    Discover the Golden Retriever, a breed celebrated for its affectionate, playful, and trainable nature. Considered a large dog, Golden Retrievers were originally bred in Scotland for hunting and retrieving game beginning in the 1860s.

  • Explore the American Staffordshire Terrier: Genuine Tips from 9,000+ Owners thumbnail

    Explore the American Staffordshire Terrier: Genuine Tips from 9,000+ Owners

    Discover the American Staffordshire Terrier, a breed celebrated for its playful, friendly, and loyal nature. Considered a medium-sized dog, American Staffordshire Terriers were originally bred in the United Kingdom for baiting bulls, fighting, and hunting beginning in the 1800s — though they're known as gentle, playful lovers today.

  • Explore the Australian Shepherd: Genuine Tips from 9,000+ Owners thumbnail

    Explore the Australian Shepherd: Genuine Tips from 9,000+ Owners

    Discover the Australian Shepherd, a breed celebrated for its trainable, playful, and affectionate nature. Considered a medium dog, Australian Shepherds were originally bred in the United States for herding beginning in the 1950s.