Rent safe and private dog parks hosted by locals

The Best Dog Trainers for Reactive Dog Training in Boston, MA of 2024

David Adams photo

David Adams

July 10, 2024

Dog Trainers

Welcome to the Sniffspot list of top-rated dog trainers for Reactive dog training in Boston, MA. Based on feedback and votes from our Reactive dog training community, we've curated a list of top-rated trainers in the Boston area.

  • Maura Porter Photo

    Maura Porter

    CPDT-KA, Mt Ida College Dog Trainer Certification graduate

    Aggressive dog training, Deaf dog training, Reactive dog training, Puppy dog training, In home dog training, Agility dog training

    South Shore, SouthCoast, 128 area

    Trainer of Low Confident Dogs. CPDT-KA Dog Trainer. Majority of client base with low-confident/reactive strong breeds. Goal is to train with respect and strength using force-free training. Weekly Reactive Dog walks. Basic and Advanced Obedience/Command work. Therapy dog (TD) prep, TD certification, CGC testing. CS works with area rescues and shelters evaluating their dogs and creating trainin...


  • Andria Young Photo

    Andria Young

    International Association of Animal Behavior Consultants - Certified Dog Behavior Consultant (CDBC) Certification Council of Professional Dog Trainers - Certified Professional Dog Trainer - Knowledge Assessed (CPDT-KA) Certified Behavior Consultant Canine - Knowledge Assessed (CBCC) Fear Free Certified Professional (FFCP) Family Dog Mediator (FDM)

    Aggressive dog training, Reactive dog training, Service dog training, Puppy dog training, In home dog training, Off leash dog training, Agility dog training

    Serving all of Massachusetts and beyond, in person and virtual instruction

    Andria Young is one of only ten Certified Canine Behavior Consultants (CCPDT and IAABC) in the entire state of Massachusetts and one of 200 in the world. With her additional certification as a Fear Free Professional and Certified Professional Dog Trainer (CPDT-KA) Andria instructs all group classes, private lessons and behavior consults.

    When not assisting students, Andria enjoys con...


  • Victoria Montgomery Photo

    Victoria Montgomery

    CPDT KA

    Reactive dog training, Puppy dog training, In home dog training

    South Shore/Plymouth county Massachusetts

    CPDT-KA. Pawsitively obedient trainer.


  • Katie Bates Photo

    Katie Bates

    Aggressive dog training, Reactive dog training, Puppy dog training, In home dog training, Off leash dog training

    Malden

    Writing about me's has never been easy. What I do know is that I love every dog I've ever come into contact with no matter the breed, creed, shape or size. I want to create a life for the families that I work with that has been made easier because they know they can rely on me. That they have someone to lean on when their dog is displaying aggressive or reactive behavior. I know that my goal in...


  • Emma Schneidkraut Photo

    Emma Schneidkraut

    KPA CTP, CPDT-KA

    Aggressive dog training, Reactive dog training, Puppy dog training, In home dog training

    Haverhill, MA, Southern NH, North Shore MA

    Emma began her training career as a training and behavior intern at The Humane Society of Boulder Valley in Boulder, Colorado. Where she provided behavior modification for shelter dogs so that they could be adoption candidates. Once moving to New England she became a Training and Behavior Coordinator at The New Hampshire SPCA, where she provided training, and enrichment for shelter dogs, group ...


  • Mathew Miller Photo

    Mathew Miller

    M.S. in Canine Human Life Science CBCC-KA CPDT-KA

    Aggressive dog training, Reactive dog training, Puppy dog training, In home dog training, Board and train dog training

    Greater Newburyport

    I've been working with dogs since 2016 and earned my CPDT - KA in 2018 since then I've earned my Masters in canine life science from Bergin University and then earned my CBCC-KA. I originally went to school for environmental science and education at the University of New England.

    After adopting my dog Trapper John who was a fearful dog, I realized I wanted to play my part in restoring...


  • Janice Gifford Photo

    Janice Gifford

    CPDT-KA, Fear Free certified professional, PPG Member

    Aggressive dog training, Reactive dog training, Puppy dog training, In home dog training

    Dorcherster, Quincy, Milton, Braintree, Weymouth, Abington, Hanover, Norwell, Pembroke, Scituate, Cohasett, Marshfield, East Bridgewater, Halifax, Hanson, Rockland, Hingham, etc.

    I started working assisting group classes 2014 and have now devoted my career to working with dogs in many different aspects including group training, in home training, behavior modification, and shelter or rescue evaluations and training.

    I work full time at PAWSitively Obedient in Pembroke/Hanover, MA and also for myself at Progressive Obedience.

    I'm very passionate about ...


  • Dory Rosati Photo

    Dory Rosati

    CPDT-KA, FPPE

    Aggressive dog training, Reactive dog training, Puppy dog training, In home dog training, Off leash dog training, Board and train dog training, Agility dog training

    Seacoast of MA & NH

    Dory is a Certified Pet Dog Trainer (CPDT-KA) serving the greater seacoast of MA and NH. She has a bachelor's degree in Animal Behavior from the University of New England and years of experience training dogs, cats, birds, and even tigers using clickers!Dory teaches group classes and private lessons using science-based training methods to improve the dog's behavior and the relationship between ...


  • Lisa Bert Photo

    Lisa Bert

    CPDT-KA, KPA CTP, licensed educator for Family Paws Parent Education

    Reactive dog training, Puppy dog training, In home dog training, Off leash dog training

    Andover, Arlington, Bedford, Belmont, Beverly, Billerica, Boxford, Burlington, Cambridge, Charlestown, Chelsea, Danvers, East Boston, Everett, Hamilton, Lexington, Lincoln, Lynn, Lynnfield, Malden, Manchester, Marblehead, Medford, Melrose, Middleton, Nahant, North Andover, North Reading, Peabody, Reading, Salem, Saugus, Somerville, Stoneham, Swampscott, Tewksbury, Topsfield, Waltham, Wakefield, Watertown, Wenham, Wilmington, Winchester, Woburn, Salem NH

    I am the proud mom of two adult children and didn't know, when we got our first dog when the children were little, just how little I knew! My good fortune to have great trainers and mentors on the cutting edge of animal-friendly training led to a career change to teach other families who need that support. That journey began in 2004 while my children were young teens and we had one dog - adding...


  • Donna Boidi Photo

    Donna Boidi

    KPA CTP CPDT-KA Master of Education

    Reactive dog training, Puppy dog training, In home dog training, Off leash dog training, Board and train dog training, Agility dog training

    South Shore (Pembroke, Hanover, Hingham, Marshfield) and remote

    While I have always been an animal lover, my love of language and learning is what drove me to become a professional dog trainer. After graduating from New York University as a linguistics major, I completed a Master of Education in Developmental Studies at Boston University while working full-time in the field of higher education. My scholarly pursuits in language acquisition and learning theo...


  • Erika Jackson Photo

    Erika Jackson

    Ccpdt- KA, IAABC Accredited trainer, CGC instructor, Do More With Your Dog Instructor, Fear Free Trainer, Fear Free Boarding and Daycare

    Reactive dog training, Service dog training, Puppy dog training, In home dog training, Off leash dog training, Board and train dog training

    Worcester County, Essex County, Middlesex country

    Erika is the owner and senior dog trainer of Blue Dingo Dogs. Growing up around dogs and horses in the grooming, training, and show worlds it was her first group class with the family dog that solidified her love of dog training. As soon as she was able she volunteered with local dog organizations and local shelters to learn as much as possible about all facets of dog training from pets to work...


  • Aubrey Sperry Photo

    Aubrey Sperry

    CDBC, CNWI, CPDT-KA, Fear Free Certified

    Aggressive dog training, Deaf dog training, Reactive dog training, Puppy dog training, In home dog training, Off leash dog training

    Jamaica Plain, Roslindale, West Roxbury, Newton, Dedham, Needham, Greater Boston

    Aubrey Sperry, CDBC, CPDT-KA, is the owner and head trainer of Sit Pretty Dog Training. She is certified by the International Association of Animal Behavior Consultants as a Certified Dog Behavior Consultant (CDBC), by the Certification Council for Professional Dog Trainers as a Certified Professional Dog Trainer – Knowledge Assessed (CPDT-KA), and by Fear Free as a Fear Free Certified Trainer....


  • Shelley Harrison Photo

    Shelley Harrison

    Ms, behavior analysis, kpt-Ctp, abcdb iaabc

    Aggressive dog training, Reactive dog training, Puppy dog training, In home dog training, Agility dog training

    Brookline, Boston, sommerville, Dedham, Wellesley, natick

    Shelley is a certified KPA-CTP dog trainer with a Masters of Science in Applied Behavior Analysis from Northeastern University, and a BA from Smith College. She is also an A-Certified Dog Behavior Consultant through the IAABC. Shelley is also currently working towards a CSAT certification (Certified Separation Anxiety Trainer) through the Malena DeMartini Separation Anxiety program. She has wor...


  • Donna Culbert Photo

    Donna Culbert

    CPDT-KA, CGC Evaluator

    Reactive dog training, Puppy dog training, In home dog training, Off leash dog training, Agility dog training

    South Shore of Massachusetts

    I own Donna's Do Right Dogs, LLC in Weymouth, MA. I am a Certified Professional Dog Trainer (CPDT-KA), a Canine Good Citizen Evaluator from the American Kennel Club and I have been in the field since 2004. I am also the Co Training Director and board member of the New England Dog Training Club in Cambridge, MA. In addition, I am member of the APDT, Association of Pet Dog Trainers, Th...


  • Diane Hanley Photo

    Diane Hanley

    CPDT-KA Certified Professional Dog Trainer

    Deaf dog training, Reactive dog training, Puppy dog training, In home dog training

    North Shore - Essex County, MA

    I have been a dog trainer since 2013. I did a 3 year training internship with Dee Ganley in Andover, NH, learning the skills of basic dog training and dog behavior. I'm a Certified Professional Dog Trainer (CPDT-KA) thru the CCPDT since 2016 and am committed to continuing my education and using humane, non-stressful training methods. Professional memberships include the Association of Pet ...


  • Ruth Hegarty Photo

    Ruth Hegarty

    certified dog trainer, certified life coach, certified dog bite safety educator, certified separation anxiety trainer, fear free shelters graduate

    Reactive dog training, Puppy dog training, In home dog training, Off leash dog training, Board and train dog training

    Cambridge, Arlington, Somerville, Lexington, Boston Metro

    Ruth Hegarty is the founder and owner of Creature Good Dog Training specializing in positively training adult adopted dogs so that they and their new families live happily ever after. Ruth is a certified dog trainer with a masters in education. She also holds certifications in life coaching and dog bite safety and is a Fear Free Shelters graduate. Ruth works with adopted dogs and their families...


  • Sophie Oldsman Photo

    Sophie Oldsman

    IAABC Accredited Dog Trainer, MS in Behavior Analysis, Fear Free certified

    Aggressive dog training, Reactive dog training, Puppy dog training, In home dog training, Off leash dog training

    waltham, belmont, arlington, winchester, lexington, needham, dedham, boston, newton, concord, weston, wayland, lincoln, wellesley, watertown, cambridge

    I am a local dog trainer who likes to educate my clients on positive reinforcement methods and the importance of force-free and fear free methods.


Sniffspot’s top-rated list of dog trainers for Reactive dog training in Boston, MA is based on rankings from our community of dog owners as well as the general public. For Reactive dog training, we received 732 total votes, resulting in 17 dog trainers who focus on Reactive dog training. Our top-ranked dog trainers are listed in order of votes, with the top-ranked trainer for Reactive dog training listed first.

Dog trainers for Reactive dog training on this list are certified by CPDT-KA, FDM, or another trusted organization. We're proud to feature Maura Porter, who has been voted the top dog trainer for Reactive dog training in Boston, MA. Maura Porter’s favorite part of their job is: Seeing the dogs quality of life change for the better.

At Sniffspot, we prioritize trust and expertise. Maura Porter, as well as the other dog trainers on this Reactive dog training list, ensures they bring the highest standards of care and training to your dog. Maura Porter encourages owners with this dog training tip: Training involves respect not yelling or barking. See it from their eyes and you will understand your dog so much better than you think you can.

Sniffspot Dog running on field

Get safe exercise for your dog by renting a private dog park near you

See The Best Trainers For Reactive Dog Training In Other Cities Near Boston


See The Best Dog Trainers By Type In Boston


Frequently Asked Questions About Reactive Dog Training in Boston, Massachusetts

How were the leading Reactive dog training trainers in Boston determined?

The best Reactive dog training trainers in Boston were identified based on 732 from local residents, highlighting those who excel in their field and are highly rated by dog owners in the area.

What are the key services offered by top Reactive dog trainers in Boston?

In Boston, prominent trainers like Maura Porter offer a variety of specialized services tailored to address specific behavioral issues. Their services are designed to meet the diverse needs of dogs in the region.

What qualifications do top Reactive dog trainers in Boston possess?

Leading trainers in Boston for Reactive dog training hold certifications such as CPDT-KA, CPDT-KA, CDBC, KPA CTP, CGC Evaluator, showcasing their dedication to maintaining high standards in professional dog training.

What is the most valuable training advice from Maura Porter for Boston dogs?

Maura Porter emphasizes that the most crucial advice for Reactive dog training training is Training involves respect not yelling or barking. See it from their eyes and you will understand your dog so much better than you think you can.This insight is vital for improving your dog’s behavior in Boston.

How do trainers in Boston keep their skills current?

Boston trainers stay updated by participating in ongoing education and certification programs, such as CPDT-KA, CPDT-KA, CDBC, KPA CTP, CGC Evaluator. They also engage with local shelters and community events to refine their skills.

Get your dog the safe enrichment they need by renting a Sniffspot

Sniffspot Dog swimming in pool
David Adams photo

David Adams

July 10, 2024

Dog Trainers

About Sniffspot

Sniffspot is a community marketplace that enables anyone to rent land by-the-hour as a safe and private dog park.

Follow us

Find Sniffspot on your favorite social media

TiktokInstagramFacebookYoutube
Related articles
The Best San Diego, California Dog Parks thumbnailThe Best San Diego, California Dog Parks
Bikejoring: What is It & How to Get Started thumbnailBikejoring: What is It & How to Get Started
Explore the Miniature Poodle: Genuine Tips from 9,000+ Owners thumbnailExplore the Miniature Poodle: Genuine Tips from 9,000+ Owners
All categories

Most recent articles

The Best San Diego, California Dog Parks thumbnailThe Best San Diego, California Dog Parks
The Best San Diego, California Dog Parks thumbnail

The Best San Diego, California Dog Parks

Bikejoring: What is It & How to Get Started thumbnailBikejoring: What is It & How to Get Started
Bikejoring: What is It & How to Get Started thumbnail

Bikejoring: What is It & How to Get Started

Explore the Miniature Poodle: Genuine Tips from 9,000+ Owners thumbnailExplore the Miniature Poodle: Genuine Tips from 9,000+ Owners
Explore the Miniature Poodle: Genuine Tips from 9,000+ Owners thumbnail

Explore the Miniature Poodle: Genuine Tips from 9,000+ Owners

Meet the Jack Russell Terrier: Advice from Real Owners thumbnailMeet the Jack Russell Terrier: Advice from Real Owners
Meet the Jack Russell Terrier: Advice from Real Owners thumbnail

Meet the Jack Russell Terrier: Advice from Real Owners

Explore the Dalmatian: Genuine Tips from Real-World Owners thumbnailExplore the Dalmatian: Genuine Tips from Real-World Owners
Explore the Dalmatian: Genuine Tips from Real-World Owners thumbnail

Explore the Dalmatian: Genuine Tips from Real-World Owners

Meet the Bernese Mountain Dog: Essential Tips from Owners thumbnailMeet the Bernese Mountain Dog: Essential Tips from Owners
Meet the Bernese Mountain Dog: Essential Tips from Owners thumbnail

Meet the Bernese Mountain Dog: Essential Tips from Owners

Top dog guides per area

Dog training guides

  • How to Deal With Food Aggression in Dogs (Facts + Infographic) thumbnail

    How to Deal With Food Aggression in Dogs (Facts + Infographic)

    Does your dog ever growl when you walk by their food dish? Maybe they get possessive of treats, carrying them far away and giving you side-eye when you start to approach — or snarling at your other pets or children if they get too close.

  • Comprehensive Guide to Scent Training for Dogs (Facts + Infographic) thumbnail

    Comprehensive Guide to Scent Training for Dogs (Facts + Infographic)

    As almost every dog owner is aware, the nose of a dog is an amazing thing. Just as they can pick up sounds we can’t hear, their sense of smell and ability to pick up scents is well beyond ours. In fact, dogs have 40 times the number of olfactory receptors as humans.

  • How Much Does it Cost to Train a Service Dog? thumbnail

    How Much Does it Cost to Train a Service Dog?

    More than 80 million Americans rely on their service dogs to help them navigate the world. Task-trained assistance animals perform a huge range of life-changing—in many cases, life-saving—services: These dogs act as eyes for visually impaired handlers, provide mobility support, alert to seizures and blood sugar crashes, interrupt anxiety attacks, remind their people to take medications, and so much more.

  • What is and How to Handle Potty Training Regression thumbnail

    What is and How to Handle Potty Training Regression

    You thought your dog was house trained. Your home was clean from puddles of pee, those dreaded middle-of-the-night bathroom breaks were behind you, and you loved every minute of dog ownership… until your four-legged best friend started using the bathroom inside again. What’s going on?

  • Coprophagia: Why Does Your Dog Eat Poop? thumbnail

    Coprophagia: Why Does Your Dog Eat Poop?

    Ah, poop. We humans think it’s disgusting… but many of our dogs seem to love the stuff. If you’re wondering why your canine companion tries to eat feces (either their own or that of other animals) you’re not alone!

Dog enrichment guides

  • The Best Dog Water Parks in the United States thumbnail

    The Best Dog Water Parks in the United States

    Do you have a water-loving dog looking to burn some energy? There are countless dog parks to visit throughout our country — but some of them become far too hot in the midday sun to be safe for your pets to play. That’s why we’ve put together a list of some of the best dog water parks throughout the United States! At these locations, your pup can frolic, splash, and swim to their heart’s content.

  • Best Toys for Herding Dogs thumbnail

    Best Toys for Herding Dogs

    * All Sniffspot articles are reviewed by certified trainers for quality, please see bottom of article for details *

  • The Best Dog Toys for Aggressive Chewers (Facts + Infographic) thumbnail

    The Best Dog Toys for Aggressive Chewers (Facts + Infographic)

    Does your dog destroy every toy you give them? Is your house littered with remnants of fabric and stuffing of all different sizes? Are you tired of investing in “indestructible” toys only for your pup to still dismantle—or worse, get bored of—them in just a few days?

  • Dog Exercise Calculator: How Much Exercise Does Your Dog Need? thumbnail

    Dog Exercise Calculator: How Much Exercise Does Your Dog Need?

    You’ve been told your dog needs regular exercise. There’s a reason “walking the dog” is a classic daily activity: Frequent excursions give your pup a chance to experience the world, maintain a healthy weight, and — most importantly — spend time with you! Consistent physical activity can also improve their strength, muscle tone, coordination, and mental ability over time.

  • Complete Guide To Herding With Dogs thumbnail

    Complete Guide To Herding With Dogs

    * All Sniffspot articles are reviewed by certified trainers for quality, please see bottom of article for details *

Dog reactivity guides

Sniffspot community guides

  • The State of Public Dog Parks Across the United States thumbnail

    The State of Public Dog Parks Across the United States

    From 2009 to 2020, there was a 40 percent increase in the development of public dog parks. Designated spots for canine exercise have become commonplace in every major city in North America — many pet owners won’t even consider renting an apartment that doesn’t have its own fenced-in pet area for their canine companions.

  • How This Family is Affording Their Dream Property Through Renting it Hourly to Dogs thumbnail

    How This Family is Affording Their Dream Property Through Renting it Hourly to Dogs

    Thousand Oaks, California has been a safe haven for Sniffspot host, Jen, since childhood. Having grown up in busy Santa Barbara, Jen, an introvert from an early age, would seek out solitude and serenity away from tourists attractions and droves of people visiting from elsewhere. “My grandparents own 60 acres about a 30 minute drive from here, and I grew up spending every summer and every holiday visiting them on the ranch,” Jen explained. “In Santa Barbara, we wouldn't go to the beach on the weekend because that's where everybody was, so you'd find places off the beaten path where the tourists weren't. For me, the ranch was just my happy place.” 

  • Host Tips: Ellen K. What Makes Sniffspot Successful for Me thumbnail

    Host Tips: Ellen K. What Makes Sniffspot Successful for Me

    Ellen is the host of Country Pasture Getaway, one of Sniffspot's most popular sniff spots. She has taken the time to write up the lessons she has learned about how to be a great sniff spot host.

  • How this Oregon Farmer is Making a Business From Renting Her Land to Dogs thumbnail

    How this Oregon Farmer is Making a Business From Renting Her Land to Dogs

    Just 20 minutes outside of the busy city of Portland, Oregon, and settled right on the banks of the Columbia River, you’ll find what countless visitors have flocked to the area in search of – mountain views, crisp, clean air, and running water for miles. What you might not expect to find, however, is a hidden oasis designed just for dogs and their people, owned and operated by a farming couple and enjoyed by visitors on two legs, and four.  

  • Host Tips: Fran T. Providing Great Guest Service at our Spot thumbnail

    Host Tips: Fran T. Providing Great Guest Service at our Spot

    Fran is the host of Ranch Setting, one of Sniffspot's most popular spots. She has taken the time to write up the lessons she has learned about how to be a great Sniffspot host.

Top dog trainers in the US

City dog parks guides

  • The Best Indoor Dog Parks in the United States thumbnail

    The Best Indoor Dog Parks in the United States

    Looking for a space to play with your dog no matter what the weather’s like outside? Look no further than our list of the best indoor dog parks in the United States! These climate-controlled spaces are growing in popularity as pet ownership increases throughout the country. As a bonus, many of them also offer dog training, boarding, grooming, or daycare services on the premises.

  • The Best Off-Leash Dog Parks in the United States thumbnail

    The Best Off-Leash Dog Parks in the United States

    Looking for the perfect place to play with your dog? We’ve got you covered! It’s hard to narrow down, but we’ve put together some of the best off-leash dog parks throughout the country so you can plan your next adventure — along with a checklist of what to bring, what to know beforehand, and some frequently asked questions.

  • The Best Las Vegas, Nevada Dog Parks thumbnail

    The Best Las Vegas, Nevada Dog Parks

    Looking for the perfect place to play with your dog in Las Vegas? We’ve got you covered! Take a look at the best local dog parks to plan for your next adventure in Sin City.

  • The Best United States Dog Parks thumbnail

    The Best United States Dog Parks

    Looking for the perfect place to play with your dog? We’ve got you covered!

  • The Best Portland, Oregon Dog Parks thumbnail

    The Best Portland, Oregon Dog Parks

    Looking for the perfect place to play with your dog in Portland? We’ve got you covered! Take a look at the best local dog parks and plan for your next adventure in the City of Roses.

Dogs breeds

  • Explore the German Shepherd Dog: Genuine Tips from Owners thumbnail

    Explore the German Shepherd Dog: Genuine Tips from Owners

    Discover the German Shepherd Dog, a breed celebrated for its intelligence, loyalty, and versatility. Known for its impressive size and smooth, graceful movements, German Shepherds excel in various roles, including as guide, therapy, bomb detection, and police dogs, while being a devoted family companion.

  • Explore the Labrador Retriever: Real Tips from Owners thumbnail

    Explore the Labrador Retriever: Real Tips from Owners

    Discover the Labrador Retriever, a breed celebrated for its playful nature, affectionate temperament, and trainability. Labradors are known for their friendly demeanor and adaptability, making them perfect family companions and versatile working dogs.

  • Explore the Golden Retriever: Genuine Tips from 9,000+ Owners thumbnail

    Explore the Golden Retriever: Genuine Tips from 9,000+ Owners

    Discover the Golden Retriever, a breed celebrated for its affectionate, playful, and trainable nature. Considered a large dog, Golden Retrievers were originally bred in Scotland for hunting and retrieving game beginning in the 1860s.

  • Explore the American Staffordshire Terrier: Genuine Tips from 9,000+ Owners thumbnail

    Explore the American Staffordshire Terrier: Genuine Tips from 9,000+ Owners

    Discover the American Staffordshire Terrier, a breed celebrated for its playful, friendly, and loyal nature. Considered a medium-sized dog, American Staffordshire Terriers were originally bred in the United Kingdom for baiting bulls, fighting, and hunting beginning in the 1800s — though they're known as gentle, playful lovers today.

  • Explore the Australian Shepherd: Genuine Tips from 9,000+ Owners thumbnail

    Explore the Australian Shepherd: Genuine Tips from 9,000+ Owners

    Discover the Australian Shepherd, a breed celebrated for its trainable, playful, and affectionate nature. Considered a medium dog, Australian Shepherds were originally bred in the United States for herding beginning in the 1950s.